30+ Years in Real Estate
100K+ Professionals Trained
1,500+ Sessions Per Year
Nationwide Reach
Agent Assessment

10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Real Estate Agent

Most hiring interviews test whether a candidate is likable in a conference room. These ten questions test something else: what they actually do when no one is calling back, when a seller says no, and when the easy excuse is sitting right there.

The interview tells you how someone talks. It rarely tells you how they will act.

Most brokers hire the same way: a conversation about experience, a few questions about goals, a gut read on whether this person will represent the brand well. All of that is reasonable, and almost none of it predicts what actually determines whether an agent produces, which is what they do in the hours nobody is watching. The candidate who interviews best is often the candidate who has practiced interviewing, not the candidate who will make the fortieth call of the week.

The questions below are built to surface behavior instead of self-description. A candidate can tell you they are a hard worker. These questions make them show you what hard work actually looks like for them, where they stall, and whether they already know it. None of them have a single right answer. What matters is whether the answer is specific, honest, and behavioral, or vague, rehearsed, and complimentary to themselves.

Here are ten questions that test behavior instead of charm.

Prefer to read this as a full story? The Interview That Told Us Nothing →

1

What will you do tomorrow morning if nobody calls you back today?

This is the single best predictor question on the list, because it asks for a plan, not a feeling. A candidate who answers with a specific next action, a block of calls, a list of past clients, a door-knock route, has already rehearsed persistence in their head. A candidate who answers with a version of "stay positive" has not yet had to build a system for the part of the job that produces no immediate reward.

2

Walk me through your calendar on a week with zero showings scheduled.

Every agent has slow weeks. The question is what fills them. A candidate who describes self-generated activity, prospecting blocks, past-client check-ins, open houses they built themselves, is describing a system. A candidate who describes waiting for the phone to ring, or for leads from a team lead, is describing a dependency they have not named yet.

3

Tell me about the last lead you stopped following up with. When, and why then?

Every agent has a lead they let go cold. The ones worth hiring can name one specifically, with a date and a reason, which means they are paying attention to their own follow-up discipline. A candidate who cannot recall a single one either has not been in the business long enough for the pattern to show up, or is not tracking follow-up closely enough to notice when it breaks down.

4

How many outbound contacts did you make last week, and how do you know?

The number matters less than the second half of the question. A candidate who can produce a count from a CRM or a call log is measuring their own activity. A candidate who estimates, "a lot," or "probably thirty," is not tracking the one behavior that predicts production better than almost any other, which means they are flying on feel rather than feedback.

5

What part of this job do you put off the longest?

Not "what is your weakness," which invites a rehearsed answer. This is a direct ask for the specific behavior a candidate avoids: prospecting, asking for referrals, the hard conversation about price, cold outreach to expireds. A candidate who can name theirs specifically and describe how they work around it is further along than one who claims to avoid nothing, which almost nobody actually does.

6

Tell me about a seller who said no to your price recommendation. What did you do next?

This question tests what happens under pushback, the moment that separates agents who can hold a position from agents who either fold immediately or dig in and damage the relationship. Listen for whether the candidate adjusted their approach to the seller's actual objection or just repeated the same argument louder.

7

What is the last piece of feedback a manager gave you that changed what you actually did, not just how you felt about it?

Most candidates will say they are coachable. This question asks for evidence. An answer with a specific behavior change, "my broker pointed out I was burying the ask in a long voicemail, so I shortened it," shows feedback turning into action. A vague answer about appreciating constructive criticism usually means the feedback got heard and not applied.

8

How do you decide when it is time to walk away from a deal that isn't moving?

Every agent eventually has to decide how long to keep working something that is not progressing. The answer reveals decision style under ambiguity: some candidates have a clear threshold, a number of weeks, a specific signal from the client. Others have no answer at all, which usually means deals quietly die on their desk rather than get actively managed to a close or a clean end.

9

What would your last broker say you avoid, and would you agree?

The second half of the question is the real test. A candidate who agrees with the broker's likely answer, even if it is unflattering, is being honest about a pattern. A candidate who immediately disputes it, or claims their broker never raised concerns, is either defensive or has never been given direct feedback, and you will not know which until you call the broker yourself.

10

If I called your last three clients right now, what is the complaint I would hear most?

Nobody has zero complaints across three clients in a relationship-driven business. A candidate who names something specific and plausible, slow to return a particular kind of message, pushed too hard on a showing schedule, is telling you the truth before you have to go find it yourself. A candidate who insists there would be nothing has either not thought about it or is not going to tell you.

A good interview finds out who talks well. A good process finds out who performs.

Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH works with brokerages and recruiting directors on real estate agent assessment, structured instruments that measure which sales behaviors a candidate will avoid and how they communicate and decide under pressure, before the hire rather than ninety days after it.

Short on time? This video recaps all 10 questions.

Read the full transcript

Most buyers and sellers hire an agent off a good first impression. Here are the ten questions that actually predict performance, not personality.

Question one. What will you do tomorrow morning if nobody calls you back today? A candidate with a real plan names a specific next action. One who just says stay positive hasn't built a system for the part of the job with no immediate reward.

Question two. Walk me through your calendar on a week with zero showings scheduled. Agents who fill slow weeks with self-generated activity are running a system. Agents who wait for the phone to ring are running on dependency.

Question three. Tell me about the last lead you stopped following up with, and why then. An agent who can name one, with a date, is paying attention to their own follow-up discipline.

Question four. How many outbound contacts did you make last week, and how do you know? A number from a CRM means they're measuring their activity. A guess means they're flying on feel.

Question five. What part of this job do you put off the longest? This isn't "what's your weakness." It's a direct ask for the behavior they actually avoid: prospecting, referrals, the hard pricing conversation.

Question six. Tell me about a seller who said no to your price recommendation, and what you did next. This tests what happens under pushback, whether they adjust or just repeat the same argument louder.

Question seven. What's the last piece of feedback a manager gave you that changed what you actually did? Most candidates say they're coachable. This question asks for evidence.

Question eight. How do you decide when it's time to walk away from a deal that isn't moving? Some agents have a clear threshold. Others have no answer, which usually means deals quietly die on their desk.

Question nine. What would your last broker say you avoid, and would you agree? Agreeing, even when it's unflattering, is honesty about a pattern. Disputing it on the spot is a different kind of answer.

Question ten. If I called your last three clients right now, what complaint would I hear most? Nobody has zero complaints in a relationship business. The agent who names something specific is telling you the truth before you have to go find it.

These ten questions separate agents who perform from agents who just interview well. For the full breakdown, and a free real estate agent assessment, visit jeffreyscottstanton dot com.

Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH is the former EVP of Learning & Development at Douglas Elliman Real Estate and the founder and Chief Learning Officer of R2R Diagnostic Group, where he helps real estate organizations and agents diagnose and fix the behavioral patterns behind inconsistent performance.