A buyer's agent said the house was overpriced. Camille almost did what she'd always done, explain the comps again. What she did instead, for the first time in eleven years, changed what happened next.
I want to tell you about an agent named Camille, because the ninety seconds I'm about to describe are the ninety seconds that convinced her she had been handling price objections wrong for eleven years, and because almost every agent I have coached has made the same mistake without ever noticing it as a mistake. Camille was representing a seller named Mr. Delacroix on a tidy brick colonial that had been priced, carefully and defensibly, at $617,000. A buyer's agent named Rob called her the morning after a showing and said, flatly, 'My clients think it's overpriced.' Camille did what almost every agent does in that exact moment. She started explaining the number again, a little more patiently this time: the comps, the updated kitchen, the finished basement, the school district. Rob listened politely and said he'd pass it along. Nothing moved. It never does, when you answer an objection with the same information that produced the objection in the first place.
What Camille didn't do, and what she has not missed since, is pause. Not for effect, and not as a negotiating trick, but because she had genuinely stopped to consider what 'overpriced' was actually doing in that sentence. Most agents hear a price objection and feel an immediate, almost physical pull to fill the silence with more justification. The silence feels like losing. It almost never is. When Camille and I talked through the call afterward, I asked her what she thought would have happened if she had simply said nothing for four seconds after Rob said 'overpriced,' and let him keep talking. She admitted she didn't know. Nobody ever finds out, because almost nobody tries it.
The second call, a week later, on a different listing, she did try it. A buyer's agent named Priscilla said the same word, 'overpriced,' about a listing Camille had priced at $449,000. Camille said, 'It sounds like the number feels high for what they're seeing,' and then stopped talking. She wasn't agreeing with the objection. She was naming it, out loud, before trying to answer it, which is a different thing entirely. Priscilla paused, then said something Camille hadn't expected: her buyers weren't actually worried about the list price. They were worried about what the inspection would turn up on a house that old, and the price objection was the easiest way to say that without committing to anything yet. The real conversation, the one about the roof and the knob-and-tube wiring in the attic, had been sitting one layer under 'overpriced' the entire time, and Camille would never have reached it by defending the number.
This is the part that doesn't make it into most negotiation training: a price objection is very often a stand-in for a different, less comfortable question the other side hasn't worked up to asking yet. Camille's old approach, re-explaining the comps, answered a question nobody had actually asked. Her new approach, asking 'what would need to be true for this to work for you,' let Priscilla's buyers say the real thing out loud, inspection contingencies and an extended due-diligence period, within about ninety seconds. Once that was on the table, it was a solvable problem. 'Overpriced' never had been.
The piece Camille struggled with longest, by her own account, was the take-away, the willingness to let a deal go without the number moving, stated once and genuinely meant. She had spent years believing that persistence was the job: keep the conversation alive, keep offering a little more, keep the seller flexible, because a deal that's still breathing can still close. What she noticed, once she started testing it, was the opposite. The moment she told a wavering buyer's agent, calmly and without a trace of desperation, that her seller was genuinely fine letting the house sit another two weeks at the current price, the pressure in the conversation moved to the other side of the table. Buyers who had been circling a number for a week made a decision within a day. The take-away isn't a bluff. It only works because it's true, and because clients can tell, almost instantly, whether an agent actually means it or is performing it.
What changed hardest for Camille wasn't any single tactic. It was the order she used them in. Her old instinct was to lead every price conversation with the number and the reasons behind it, and then spend the rest of the call defending whatever she'd led with. Her new instinct is to let the objection surface first, label it, ask the calibrated question, and only then, once she actually knows what she's negotiating, return to the number, specific rather than round, stated once, without hedging. A specific figure, she found, invites a specific response. A round one invites a round argument, because a round number signals that there's slack in it, whether or not there actually is.
There was a third habit Camille built on top of the first two, almost by accident. A buyer's agent named Theo, negotiating on behalf of a young couple, asked her a hard question directly: would her seller come down to $435,000 on the spot, yes or no. The old Camille would have answered instantly, the way she'd been trained to, because a fast answer feels confident. The new Camille let a real, visible pause sit there, long enough that Theo asked if she was still on the line. She was. She was thinking, honestly, about whether the number worked, and she said so. Theo told her afterward that the pause was what convinced his buyers the number she eventually gave was real and not an opening position dressed up as a final one. An instant answer to a hard price question reads as rehearsed, whether it is or not. A genuine pause reads as exactly what it is.
On the same deal, once the pause had done its work, Camille didn't counter with one number. She gave Theo's buyers two real paths: the full price with a faster close, or four thousand dollars off with the seller keeping two extra weeks to coordinate his own move. Both were acceptable to Mr. Delacroix's counterpart on that listing. Neither was a decoy built to make the other look better. What changed was the shape of the decision in front of the buyers. They weren't choosing between agreeing and refusing anymore. They were choosing between two things their seller had already said yes to, which is a far easier choice for almost anyone to make, and they made it inside a day.
'Overpriced' was never the objection. It was the easiest word for a worry Camille's clients hadn't worked up to naming yet.
The Delacroix listing, the brick colonial, sold six weeks after that first call with Rob, at $609,000, eight thousand under list and comfortably within the range Mr. Delacroix had set as acceptable before the first showing ever happened. What took those six weeks wasn't a better argument for the price. It was Camille finally asking Rob's buyers, directly, what would need to be true for the number to work for them, instead of handing them the same comps a second time and hoping persistence would eventually wear the objection down. It turned out the real sticking point was never the price at all. It was a closing date that conflicted with a lease the buyers hadn't mentioned, and once that was on the table, the eight thousand dollars took four minutes to agree on.
Camille still gets price objections every week, the same word, 'overpriced,' in roughly the same tone, on roughly the same kinds of houses. What she no longer does is answer it with the number. She answers it with a pause, and then a question, and lets whoever raised the objection tell her what they actually meant by it. Most of the time, it was never about the price at all. It was about something the other side hadn't worked up to saying yet, and the agents who keep explaining the number instead of asking what's underneath it are the ones who never find out what that something was.
Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH works with agents, teams, and brokerages on influence and persuasion in real estate: what actually earns the yes, and the agent-side patterns that quietly cost agents their standing in the room.
Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH is the former EVP of Learning & Development at Douglas Elliman Real Estate and the founder and Chief Learning Officer of R2R Diagnostic Group, where he helps real estate organizations and agents diagnose and fix the behavioral patterns behind inconsistent performance.