30+Years Experience
100K+Professionals Trained
1,500+Sessions Per Year
NationwideReach
Leadership and Team Leaders

The Tuesday Test

He could recite his own leadership training almost word for word. His team, asked separately, could not describe one thing that had actually changed because of it.

A workbook with his name already in the sleeve

Derek had been to four leadership programs in six years, counting the one his brokerage flew everyone in for and the one he paid for himself because a colleague recommended it. Each one left him genuinely energized, full of language he liked and meant to use, and each workbook ended up in the same desk drawer within about three weeks, half-finished, under the one before it. He was not being lazy. He simply never had a way of knowing, on an ordinary Tuesday, whether anything from any of those rooms was actually present in how he ran his team, as opposed to merely present in his vocabulary when someone asked him about leadership.

He kept buying training for a diagnosis he never made

Whenever the team went flat, Derek's instinct was to add something: a motivational speaker for the next sales meeting, a new lead source, occasionally a pep talk he'd stayed up writing. What he never did first was ask which of three separate things was actually broken. It might be the system underneath the team, the leads and the process. It might be management attention, meaning whether anyone was actually watching the behaviors that lead to a sale. Or it might be something specific to one person. Each of those has a different fix, and Derek had spent years applying the same general-purpose fix, a speech or a new tool, to all three, which is a little like replacing the furnace because one room is cold.

The clearest version of that same blind spot had a name and a face on his team: an agent everyone liked, well trained, who simply was not prospecting, and who had been not-prospecting for long enough that Derek had started to think of it as just her personality. His fix, every time it came up, was another class. She attended them, took notes, and the following Monday was exactly like the Monday before it, because the problem had never been what she knew.

It was a coach, not Derek, who finally asked the obvious question he had never gotten around to asking her directly: what actually happens, specifically, in the moment before you were going to make that call and didn't. Her answer had nothing to do with not knowing how to prospect. She knew exactly how. The gap was behavioral, something closer to dread than to a skills deficit, and once Derek had language for the distinction he could see it in two other agents he had been quietly misdiagnosing the same way for years.

The standard that depended on who was having a good month

Derek's best producer skipped the Monday meeting more often than anyone else, missed CRM updates nobody else got away with missing, and was short with the transaction coordinator in a way that generated a quiet complaint more than once. Derek let all of it go, because the numbers were the numbers, and he told himself the standard still applied to everyone in principle. A newer agent on the team missed one deadline the same month, for a smaller and more defensible reason, and got a direct conversation about it within the week. Derek did not experience himself as playing favorites. He experienced himself as being busy and picking his battles. The team experienced something else entirely, and had quietly started citing his top producer as proof that the rules were optional if your numbers were good enough.

The sentence that meant nothing by the third time he said it

"We really need to be better about follow-up, guys" was a sentence Derek reached for in some form most weeks, and he believed, saying it, that he was setting a standard. He asked three agents separately, almost as an experiment after a coaching session suggested it, what the actual follow-up standard on the team was. He got three different answers, none of them wrong exactly, because none of them had ever been given anything specific enough to be wrong about. A mood is not a standard. A standard names the behavior, the measure, and the moment someone checks it, and Derek's version of leadership language had never gotten more specific than the mood.

His sales meetings had the identical shape. They ended on energy, people clapping for whoever had just closed something, and then everyone went back to their desks having agreed to nothing in particular. Nothing from one Monday ever came up at the next one, because nothing had been written down, which meant agreement in the room had quietly become the entire product of the meeting, with no behavior attached to it afterward.

The one-to-one that was always reviewing last quarter

His one-to-ones opened the same way nearly every time: "how's it going," followed by whichever difficult client happened to be top of mind for the agent that week. It felt like connection, and in a narrow sense it was. It was also, Derek eventually realized, a conversation almost entirely about the past, because closings lag the behavior that produced them by two or three months, so by the time a number was low enough to discuss, the week that actually caused it was long gone and impossible to coach directly. Feedback followed the same lag. It arrived as a general comment dropped into a group setting, vague enough that the agent receiving it had nothing specific to change and often spent the rest of the meeting quietly defending themselves instead of hearing it.

Covering the gap instead of closing it

Derek had gotten this job by being the best agent on the team, and under pressure that is exactly who he reverted to. When production dipped, his own production rose to meet it: he would take the hard listing appointment himself, close the deal that was slipping, and quietly rescue the month. It felt like leadership in the moment. What it actually taught the team was that a gap would always get covered by someone else, which is a very efficient way to train a group of adults not to close their own gaps. His calendar, when a coach finally asked to see it rather than ask him to describe it, told a more honest story than Derek had been telling himself.

One specific Thursday made the pattern impossible to ignore once he saw it written down: a newer agent's listing appointment had gone sideways, and instead of sending him back in with a debrief and a second try, Derek simply took the appointment the following week and closed it himself. The agent thanked him. Neither of them discussed what had actually gone wrong in the room the first time, which meant the one appointment that could have taught that agent something had instead taught him that Derek would eventually step in.

What the ninety days finally showed him

The thing that changed Derek's leadership was not a fifth workshop. It was being asked, before anything else happened, to write down exactly what would be checked again in ninety days: whether the one-to-ones were actually happening every week, whether the standard got restated in the same specific language by every agent who was asked, and whether the leading behaviors, the calls and the appointments, had moved at all. Ninety days later he had an answer in his own numbers rather than in an evaluation form filled out on the day of a workshop, and for the first time one of the four programs had left something behind that he could point to instead of just describe.

What had actually changed was smaller than he expected and more durable than anything from the first three workshops. He still opens some one-to-ones with "how's it going." He no longer lets that be the whole conversation, and he writes down, every single time, the one leading number he is going to ask about again the following week, so the question has somewhere to land besides his memory. The test he trusts now is not whether a session felt good in the room. It is what he does differently on the following Tuesday, which turned out to be the only question that was ever going to tell him anything, about himself or about the next program he is tempted to buy.

Want the full nine, with the before, the after and the evidence for each? 9 Things Leadership Training for Real Estate Team Leaders Must Change lays them out one at a time.

Your team knows what to do. Leadership is finding out why they are not doing it.

Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH delivers The Psychology of Leadership, Leadership Is Language, and Why Teams Don't Execute to brokerages, teams, and associations, and coaches managing brokers and team leaders one on one. Real Estate Leadership Training for Brokers and Team Leaders explains the full framework.

Real estate leadership, in order.

Every page on this site about leading a real estate team, office, or brokerage, written by Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH, former EVP of Learning and Development at Douglas Elliman.

Dr. Jeffrey Scott Stanton, DCH is the former EVP of Learning & Development at Douglas Elliman Real Estate and the founder and Chief Learning Officer of R2R Diagnostic Group, where he helps real estate organizations and agents diagnose and fix the behavioral patterns behind inconsistent performance.